USFWS Proposes Critical Habitat for Freshwater Mussels

Protecting Critical Habitat for Freshwater Mussels

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) recently proposed new critical habitat designations for four endangered freshwater mussels: the rayed bean, sheepnose, snuffbox, and spectaclecase. Spanning 3,974 river miles across 17 states, this proposal will establish critical habitat protection in areas where none previously existed. These designations emphasize the importance of safeguarding these essential species and their habitats.

Freshwater mussels are vital to aquatic ecosystems and are among the most imperiled species in North America. They face significant pressures that have led them to dramatic population declines. The proposed critical habitat designations aim to protect these species from further decline while encouraging coordinated conservation efforts that benefit entire ecosystems.

What’s Threatening These Mussels?

Freshwater mussels face a range of growing pressures. While each of the four mussel species faces unique challenges, several overarching threats contribute to their decline:

Endangered Spectaclecase Mussels Being Measured by Expert Malacologist During EnviroScience Mussel Survey

Endangered Spectaclecase Mussels

Habitat Modification and Fragmentation

Habitat modification, such as dam construction and other waterway alterations, profoundly impacts mussel populations.

Dams disrupt the natural flow of rivers, hinder sediment transport, and create conditions unsuitable for mussel survival. These changes harm species like the spectaclecase, which relies on deep, flowing pools.

Additionally, channelization and sedimentation from agricultural runoff further degrades habitats by smothering mussels and impairing their ability to filter nutrients effectively.

Endangered Rayed Bean Mussel Being Measured by Expert Malacologist During EnviroScience Mussel Survey

Endangered Rayed Bean Mussel

Pollution and Contaminants

Polluted runoff from agricultural, industrial, and urban areas introduces harmful substances like heavy metals, pesticides, and excess nutrients into waterways.

Elevated nutrient levels can lead to Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs) that deplete oxygen in the water and suffocate mussels.

Species such as the rayed bean, which depend on pristine habitats, are particularly vulnerable to poor water quality.

Endangered Snuffbox Mussel Being Measured by Expert Malacologist During EnviroScience Mussel Survey

Endangered Snuffbox Mussel

Invasive Species

Non-native species, like zebra mussels, pose a dual threat to native mussels. They compete for resources while also physically attaching to the shells of native mussels, restricting movement and feeding.

This is particularly damaging for species like the snuffbox, which relies on specific host fish for reproduction and is particularly vulnerable in ecosystems disrupted by invasives.

Endangered Sheepnose Mussel Being Measured by Expert Malacologist During EnviroScience Mussel Survey

Endangered Sheepnose Mussel

Declining Host Fish Populations

The unique life cycle of freshwater mussels depends on specific fish species that serve as hosts for their larvae.

The loss or reduction of these host fish populations due to overfishing, habitat degradation, or pollution further threatens mussel reproduction.

This is a concern for species like the sheepnose, which rely on these essential relationships to sustain their populations.

Why Critical Habitat Designations Matter

Critical habitat designations are a key tool under the Endangered Species Act, identifying areas essential for the survival and recovery of listed species. These designations do not prevent land use or development outright but require federal agencies to consult with USFWS to ensure activities in these areas do not adversely modify the habitat.

The proposed designations introduce protections in areas where none previously existed and span river systems in states from Alabama to Wisconsin. These areas include habitats characterized by stable substrates, clean water, and healthy aquatic vegetation—conditions essential for mussel survival.  By designating these areas as critical habitats, the USFWS is helping protect mussels and the broader ecosystem services they provide, such as improving water quality and supporting biodiversity.

How EnviroScience Can Assist

Navigating the regulatory requirements surrounding critical habitat designations can be complex. With over 30 years of experience, EnviroScience’s team of malacologists and environmental professionals is uniquely equipped to help clients navigate regulatory landscapes. Our services include:

EnviroScience Malacologists Perform Endangered Mussel Survey

EnviroScience Malacologists Perform Endangered Mussel Survey

Endangered Mussel Surveys:

We assess species presence and habitat suitability.

Habitat Restoration:

Our team works to mitigate the impacts of development and pollution.

Regulatory Compliance Support:

We provide expert guidance to ensure projects meet federal, state, and local requirements for work in designated critical habitat areas.

By partnering with EnviroScience, clients can ensure their projects comply with regulatory standards while supporting essential conservation efforts. Visit our Endangered Mussel Surveys page to learn how we can assist with endangered mussel surveys and compliance needs.

EnviroScience remains dedicated to supporting clients and conserving freshwater ecosystems. Contact us today to discover how we can help you navigate these changes and contribute to protecting these vital species.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




Eastern Hellbender Proposed for Endangered Species

Eastern Hellbender Proposed for Endangered Species Listing

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) has proposed listing the eastern hellbender (Cryptobranchus alleganiensis alleganiensis) as an endangered species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). This announcement, published in the Federal Register on December 13, 2024, initiates a 60-day public comment period ending February 11, 2025. Stakeholders are encouraged to submit comments via regulations.gov under docket number FWS-R3-ES-2024-0152.

Eastern Hellbender as Captured by EnviroScience Herpetologist Stan Boder

What Is the Eastern Hellbender?

The eastern hellbender, also known as the “snot otter” or “mud devil,” is North America’s largest salamander, reaching lengths of up to 30 inches. These aquatic giants live exclusively in cool, clear, fast-moving streams and rivers across 16 states, including Ohio, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, and New York. They spend a lot or most of their lives under large, flat rocks on the streambed, where they feed on crayfish and other small aquatic organisms. With lifespans reaching up to 30 years, hellbenders are long-lived but highly vulnerable to environmental changes.

Why Is the Eastern Hellbender Population Declining?

Eastern Hellbender as Captured by EnviroScience Herpetologist Stan BoderDespite their resilience, eastern hellbender populations have experienced sharp declines. Habitat destruction and modification due to sedimentation, water quality degradation, and stream disturbances have severely impacted their ecosystems. Diseases such as chytrid fungus and illegal collection, particularly for the pet trade, present ongoing threats. These compounding factors have driven the USFWS to propose listing the eastern hellbender as endangered to protect the species from extinction.

Proposed Protections for the Eastern Hellbender

The ESA listing would prohibit activities that harm, harass, or kill the eastern hellbender. It would also require federal agencies to collaborate with the USFWS to conserve the species and its habitat. However, the USFWS is not designating critical habitat for the eastern hellbender due to concerns over illegal collection.

The proposed protections aim to reduce threats and stabilize populations by addressing key issues such as habitat destruction and illegal collection. These measures will be crucial in reversing the species’ decline and ensuring survival.

How the Eastern Hellbender Listing Impacts Development Projects

The proposed listing has significant implications for the development, agriculture, and utilities industries. Projects that intersect with eastern hellbender habitats will need to comply with ESA regulations to minimize impacts on the species and its habitat.

EnviroScience’s Expertise in Eastern Hellbender Compliance

Eastern Hellbender as Captured by EnviroScience Herpetologist Stan BoderAs a trusted leader in environmental consulting, EnviroScience, Inc. is uniquely positioned to help clients navigate the challenges associated with eastern hellbender conservation and compliance. Our nationally recognized team of biologists and ecologists offers specialized services, including:

  • Habitat assessments to determine if there is potential habitat for the species and the likelihood of species occurrence.
  • Species-specific surveys conducted by permitted specialists to determine the presence or probable absence of the species.
  • Development of conservation measures and mitigation strategies to minimize project impacts.
  • Assistance with permitting and regulatory compliance to keep projects on track.

With over 35 years of experience, EnviroScience has successfully helped clients meet ESA requirements while ensuring their projects proceed smoothly. Whether you’re planning a development project, managing water resources, or restoring natural habitats, we provide the expertise you need.

We Can Help Protect Your Project and Your Plans

The eastern hellbender’s plight underscores the importance of balancing development with conservation. If you have questions about how this proposed listing may affect your project, we’re here to help. Visit our Threatened & Endangered Species Services page to learn how EnviroScience can support you.

By working with trusted environmental professionals, you can ensure your projects meet regulatory requirements while contributing to the protection of this iconic species.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




USFWS Proposes Monarch Butterfly as Threatened Species

Monarch Butterfly Captured by EnviroScience Wetland Biologist Adam Behringer

Proposed Threatened Listing for the Monarch Butterfly

Monarch Butterfly Caterpillar Captured in Milkweed by EnviroScience Pollinator Biologist Carlyn RocazellaToday, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) announced its proposed listing of the monarch butterfly (Danaus plexippus plexippus) as a threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). This proposal includes species-specific protections and flexibilities designed to encourage conservation efforts. Additionally, the USFWS plans to designate critical habitat in California’s overwintering grounds.

Understanding the Monarch Butterfly’s Decline

Monarch Butterfly Captured by EnviroScience GIS Operations Manager Anna PiazzaThe monarch butterfly, renowned for its extensive migration across North America, has experienced significant population declines in recent decades. Factors contributing to this decline include habitat loss, climate change, and pesticide exposure. The proposed listing aims to prevent further decline and promote recovery by implementing tailored protections.

How the 4(d) Rule Supports Monarch Butterfly Conservation

Monarch Butterfly Captured in Meadow by EnviroScience Wetland Biologist Adam BehringerUnder the ESA, a “threatened” designation allows for customized protections through a 4(d) rule. The USFWS’s proposed 4(d) rule for the monarch butterfly seeks to incentivize proactive conservation efforts and permit activities that have beneficial or minimal impacts on the species, provided they do not threaten the overall population. This approach balances species protection with ongoing land management and conservation practices.

The proposal also includes designating 4,395 acres in seven coastal California counties as critical habitat. This designation focuses on areas essential for the monarch’s overwintering, aiming to safeguard and restore these vital habitats.

The USFWS is conducting a 90-day public comment period, open through March 2025, to gather input and any new information regarding the proposed listing and critical habitat designation. Following this period, the USFWS will review the comments and issue a final rule. If the monarch butterfly is listed, protections would be implemented after the final rule’s publication.

What This Means for Conservation and Compliance

This proposed listing has significant implications for landowners, businesses, and conservationists. While it introduces protections for the monarch butterfly, it also creates opportunities for proactive habitat restoration and management.

How EnviroScience Can Help with Habitat Needs

Monarch Butterfly Caterpillar Captured by EnviroScience Wetland Biologist Adam BehringerEnviroScience is committed to assisting clients in navigating the implications of this proposed listing. Our team of biologists, ecologists, and environmental professionals offers expertise in habitat assessment, conservation planning, and regulatory compliance to support efforts in protecting the monarch butterfly and other threatened species.

For more information or to discuss how this proposal may affect your projects, please get in touch with us at https://www.enviroscienceinc.com/contact-us/.

Take Action: Protecting the Monarch Butterfly Together

The proposed listing provides an opportunity to reverse the monarch butterfly’s decline through collaborative conservation efforts. Whether you are managing land, planning a project, or simply passionate about the environment, this is a critical time to contribute to recovering one of North America’s most iconic species.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




National Pollution Prevention Day 2024: Top Ten List

National Pollution Prevention Day 2024

It’s National Pollution Prevention Day 2024, and we’ve assembled an infographic of the Top Ten list of ways you can help reduce pollution in your everyday life.


At EnviroScience, Inc., we specialize in services that address pollution and environmental compliance. Our offerings include Environmental Inspection Services, Mitigation Planning, PFAS Sampling & Remediation Services, Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plans (SWPPP), and Sustainability Services to help clients adhere to environmental regulations and implement effective pollution control measures.

Learn more about our services at https://www.enviroscienceinc.com/services/.

By integrating these practices into daily life and collaborating with environmental experts like EnviroScience, we can make significant strides in pollution prevention and environmental preservation.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




2024 Mike Trump Chili Cookoff: A Recipe for Giving Back

On Thursday, November 21, EnviroScience’s Corporate Responsibility Committee (CRC) hosted the 2024 Mike Trump Chili Cookoff. This annual event is not just about delicious chili; it’s a way to honor the generosity and spirit of Mike Trump, a beloved colleague who exemplified kindness, service, and dedication to helping others.

EnviroScience Honors Beloved Employee Mike Trump at Annual Chilli Cookoff

Staff members from EnviroScience and their families submitted chili entries this year. For a charitable donation of $15 each, employees could enjoy a lunch that included 15 different chili tastings, salads, side dishes, bread, and desserts, allowing them to vote for this year’s winner. In alignment with our environmental commitment to sustainability, participants were encouraged to bring their own utensils, bowls, cups, and muffin tins to save on tasting cups!

Akron-Canton Regional Foodbank: A Legacy of Hope and Service

The Akron-Canton Regional Foodbank (ACRF) has been a cornerstone of compassion in Northeast Ohio since 1982, addressing hunger across eight counties. In 2022, the ACRF distributed 30 million pounds of food and other essential items, providing 23.3 million meals, with the support of 7,400 volunteers who donated over 55,000 hours of service.

In 2023, the ACRF experienced unprecedented demand, serving more people than ever. They reported a 26% increase in service compared to 2022, attributing the surge to economic challenges and the conclusion of pandemic-era benefits.

EnviroScience Honors Beloved Employee Mike Trump at Annual Chilli Cookoff

The ACRF operates under a mission to lead a collaborative network that empowers people to experience healthy and hunger-free lives, focusing on values such as compassion, collaboration, service, integrity, inclusion, and innovation. As a member of Feeding America, they work tirelessly to serve communities where hunger is most prevalent, especially among children and seniors.

Proceeds from our annual chili cookoff benefiting the ACRF will support their ongoing efforts to combat hunger in the region.

2024 Chili Cookoff Yields Over 4,200 Meals to Underserved Families

Tim Willaman Passes the Coveted 1st Place Wooden Spoon to 2024 Mike Trump Chili Cookoff Winner Alison Frohn

This year’s event was a resounding success, raising over $700 to support the Akron-Canton Regional Foodbank’s Double Dollar Day on December 2, 2024. Generous partners, including The J.M. Smucker Company, T.L. Squire, and others, have pledged to match donations up to $92,500, doubling our contribution.

The Akron-Canton Regional Foodbank estimates that every $10 donated provides 30 meals, meaning our collective efforts will supply over 4,200 meals to those in need.

The cookoff featured a variety of delicious chili recipes. Congratulations to our top finishers:

  • 1st Place: Alison Frohn with her ‘Netflix and Chili’ recipe
  • 2nd Place: Cam Turney
  • 3rd Place (Tie): Chuck Howard, Michael Whitacre, and Lynn Myers

EnviroScience Honors Beloved Employee Mike Trump at Annual Chilli CookoffA special thank you to Erik Matonak, Becki Pedone, Mary January, and all the “secret cleaning elves” who ensured the event area was spotless afterward.

To learn more about similar initiatives and methods for you or your company to donate to the Akron-Canton Regional Foodbank and how your contributions make a difference, visit their official page at https://www.akroncantonfoodbank.org/.

We encourage everyone to continue supporting our community and honoring Mike Trump’s legacy through participation in future events.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




Founder Marty Hilovsky Earns OLMS Lifetime Achievement Award

EnviroScience Founder, Martin "Marty" Hilovsky, Receives Ohio Lake Management Society's (OLMS) Prestigious Lifetime Achievement Award

EnviroScience proudly announces that our founder, Martin “Marty” Hilovsky, has been honored with the Ohio Lake Management Society (OLMS) Lifetime Achievement Award at the 53rd Annual Water Association of Ohio (WMAO) Meeting and Symposium. This prestigious accolade recognizes Marty’s significant contributions to environmental science and his unwavering commitment to preserving Ohio’s natural resources.

Marty’s journey began with his academic training as a biologist and ecologist at Kent State University. He served as a state regulator with the Ohio EPA and later as a consultant for NASA. In 1989, he founded EnviroScience, Inc., which has since evolved into a nationally recognized leader in lake management, harmful algae blooms, ecological restoration, endangered species consulting, bioassay testing, and regulatory compliance. Marty is acclaimed for commercializing the “MiddFoil Process,” a method employing native weevils to control Eurasian water milfoil.

Under Marty’s leadership, EnviroScience has grown into a team of over 160 professionals dedicated to delivering innovative environmental solutions nationwide. His vision fostered a culture of “Empowered Employees,” emphasizing teamwork, client advocacy, respect, accountability, quality, and safety. Marty’s philosophy is encapsulated in his belief: “I never thought of it as ‘my’ company…it was and continues to be our company.”

EnviroScience Founder, Martin "Marty" Hilovsky, Receives Ohio Lake Management Society's (OLMS) Prestigious Lifetime Achievement Award

The award ceremony took place at the 53rd Annual WMAO Meeting and Symposium in Worthington, Ohio, and was attended by EnviroScience’s Director of Laboratory Services, Jen Vydra, and Algal/Toxin Operations Manager, Brad Bartelme. Their presence underscored the company’s ongoing commitment to environmental stewardship and excellence.

EnviroScience remains dedicated to upholding the high standards set by Marty, continuing to provide exceptional environmental consulting services, and contributing positively to our communities. The entire team at EnviroScience congratulates him on this well-earned and deserved award. Congratulations, Marty!


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




USFWS Announces Final Recovery Plan for Endangered Mussels

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) recently announced the Final Recovery Plan for four endangered freshwater mussels: the Rayed Bean, Sheepnose, Snuffbox, and Spectaclecase. These species, listed under the Endangered Species Act in 2012, have been severely impacted by habitat destruction, pollution, invasive species, and changes to river systems.  These listings, while likely necessary for the conservation of the species, can complicate project design and delivery.

EnviroScience is proud to provide solutions with our nationally recognized malacology team, whose expertise has been instrumental in endangered mussel surveys and habitat assessments.  In many cases, EnviroScience has worked with clients and resource agencies to find opportunities to maintain project delivery goals while supporting key goals of endangered species recovery plans, like the PennDOT Hunter Station Project.

Key Points of the Recovery Plan

The USFWS recovery plan takes a strategic approach focused on protecting and enhancing mussel populations and their habitats. Critical aspects of the plan include:

Captive Rearing and Population Restoration
By breeding these mussels in controlled environments, USFWS aims to bolster population numbers in areas where they were historically found, ensuring genetic diversity and demographic stability.

Habitat Protection and Restoration
The plan emphasizes enhancing river habitats by removing unsound dams, restoring riparian buffers, and reconnecting fragmented waterways. These actions support mussels and the entire ecosystem that relies on healthy rivers.

Public and Partner Engagement
Successful recovery hinges on collaboration between federal, state, and local agencies and private organizations. Public involvement in conservation is essential, as are educational efforts to raise awareness about the importance of mussels in water quality and ecosystem health.

Threat Alleviation and Research
To address the persistent threats facing these mussels, the plan includes researching the effects of climate change, pollution, and invasive species, with targeted actions to mitigate these threats over time.

Each of these initiatives is intended to guide the mussels toward recovery without imposing new regulatory requirements. Instead, the plan serves as a cooperative framework for conservation across all stakeholders.

Mussel Species Overview

Rayed Bean (Villosa fabalis)
A small, delicate mussel primarily found in moderate-flow rivers across the Great Lakes and Ohio River basins.

Sheepnose (Plethobasus cyphyus)
Known for its resilience, the sheepnose inhabits larger river systems with moderate currents.

Snuffbox (Epioblasma triquetra)
A medium-sized mussel, the snuffbox is particularly sensitive to pollution and habitat disruption.

Spectaclecase (Cumberlandia monodonta)
One of the longest-lived freshwater mussels, the Spectaclecase thrives in sheltered riverine habitats. 

EnviroScience is at the forefront of endangered mussel conservation consulting

In general, freshwater mussels are essential “keystone species” to the health of freshwater systems. Their unique ability to filter water enhances water quality, benefiting aquatic ecosystems and human communities.  For example, work by Caryn C. Vaughn, Ph.D., has shown links between freshwater mussel communities and improved fish populations.

EnviroScience’s Role in Navigating Mussel Conservation

EnviroScience is at the forefront of endangered mussel conservation consulting, offering specialized services like biological assessments, biological evaluations, habitat conservation plans, field site assessments/due diligence, quantitative population surveys, habitat assessments, and mitigation solutions.

Our biologists are U.S. Fish and Wildlife-approved mussel surveyors with expertise in underwater diving that facilitates accurate freshwater mussel density estimates. We utilize advanced GPS/GIS technology for precise mapping and monitoring and the latest mussel Passive Integrated Transponder (PIT) tagging techniques to aid conservation efforts. EnviroScience’s scientists also bring a strong understanding of regulatory compliance, streamlining project specifications to meet state and federal requirements seamlessly.

For more information on our endangered mussel survey services, visit https://www.enviroscienceinc.com/services/endangered-mussel-surveys/.

We work with our clients to provide value-added project solutions to endangered species while supporting conservation plans. Contact us today to find out more.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




ESA Compliance for NLEB & Tricolored Bats: Updated Guidance

As part of its ongoing commitment to protect endangered species, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) recently introduced updated tools and guidance to aid developers, landowners, and project managers in achieving compliance with the Endangered Species Act (ESA) for the northern long-eared bat (NLEB) and tricolored bat (TCB). For industries managing compliance across construction, wind energy, sustainable forestry, and beyond, understanding ESA compliance for the NLEB and TCB is essential under the recent USFWS updates.

With over 35 years of expertise, EnviroScience offers unparalleled consulting services designed to help clients effectively apply these updates, minimize project delays, and maintain adherence to federal guidelines.

Federally Endangered Northern Long-eared Bat: USFWS Guidelines for ESA Compliance

Federally Endangered Northern Long-eared Bat

Understanding the New ESA Compliance Guidelines and Tools

Effective October 23, 2024, the USFWS tools support stakeholders in navigating ESA requirements for the recently reclassified NLEB and the proposed listing of the TCB. These tools streamline consultation and compliance processes, offering a clear path forward for projects that intersect with the habitats of these endangered bats. Notable updates include:

  • Range-Wide Determination Key (DKey):
    Integrated within the USFWS IPaC tool, this DKey enables project managers to automate bat impact assessments and secure ESA compliance faster. Its automated process reduces project bottlenecks and facilitates efficient project planning for most sectors.
  • Sector-Specific Guidelines:
    The USFWS guidance is tailored to critical industries, with options for voluntary environmental reviews for development projects and distinct compliance solutions for wind facilities and forestry. Each guidance type offers flexibility while emphasizing bat conservation and regulatory predictability.

These updates benefit project stakeholders by clarifying the steps for ESA consultation, reducing regulatory uncertainties, and helping manage project schedules efficiently.

How EnviroScience Helps You Navigate ESA Compliance

As a leader in endangered species consulting, EnviroScience provides comprehensive services to ensure your project aligns with USFWS requirements without compromising timelines. Our team’s knowledge of bat ecology and extensive experience in regulatory compliance allow us to deliver services tailored precisely to industry needs. Whether your project involves wind energy, commercial construction, or sustainable forestry, EnviroScience’s services cover every stage of the ESA compliance process, including:

  • Specialized Bat Surveys and Impact Assessments:
    Our team of biologists and ecologists conducts detailed bat surveys that provide critical insights into bat presence, helping to guide compliance strategies effectively.
  • Mitigation Strategy Development:
    We craft customized mitigation plans to minimize project impacts on endangered bat habitats, ensuring regulatory adherence while allowing project continuity.
  • Ongoing Support for Compliance:
    From initial project planning to mitigation and monitoring, EnviroScience offers clients the guidance needed to implement USFWS’s tools and resources successfully.

Proposed Endangered Tricolored Bat: USFWS Guidance for ESA Compliance

Proposed Endangered Tricolored Bat

Why Choose EnviroScience as Your Bat Conservation Partner?

With a proven track record across multiple industries, EnviroScience has built a reputation for excellence in bat conservation and ESA compliance. Our consulting team’s decades of experience working with USFWS and other regulatory bodies make us a preferred partner for complex projects nationwide.

By partnering with EnviroScience, you gain:

  • Industry-Specific Expertise:
    We understand the unique regulatory needs of sectors ranging from wind energy to private landowners, enabling us to tailor our services to each client.
  • Efficient Compliance Solutions:
    Our expertise ensures that your project can achieve ESA compliance quickly and accurately, helping to keep timelines on track and budgets in check.
  • Commitment to Conservation:
    While we support your project’s success, we also work closely with regulatory agencies to ensure that endangered species like the NLEB and TCB are protected for future generations.

Discover How EnviroScience Can Support Your Project

Whether you’re developing land, managing forest resources, or operating a wind facility, EnviroScience’s expert bat consulting services are designed to help you meet regulatory requirements without compromising your operational goals. Visit our Endangered Bat Surveys webpage to learn more about our services.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




Navigating Ohio EPA’s New Wetlands & Streams Regulations

Entrust EnviroScience Experts to Help Navigate the Latest Ohio EPA Regulations on Wetlands and StreamsThe Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)’s Division of Surface Water recently implemented significant updates to regulations on wetlands and streams, impacting industries from transportation to development and infrastructure.

These changes, effective as of August 2024, were outlined by 401/Wetlands Manager Anna Kamnyev during her October 8, 2024, presentation at the Ohio Transportation Engineering Conference (OTEC). Below is a summary of the primary changes and how EnviroScience can assist clients in staying compliant amid these regulatory updates.

Understanding the New Regulations

Integration of Mitigation Guidance and Senate Bill 9
Effective August 1, 2024, the EPA incorporated mitigation guidance per House Bill 175 into Ohio Administrative Code (OAC) sections 3745-1-50 through 3745-1-54 and 3745-32-01 through 3745-32-04. These sections establish wetland water quality standards and the 401 Water Quality Certification process, ensuring that mitigation for activities affecting wetlands and streams is both effective and consistent.

Adoption of the Ohio Stream Assessment Method (OSAM)
The Ohio Stream Assessment Method (OSAM) is a new functional assessment tool adapted from the Georgia Stream Quantification Tool (SQT) and Stream Functional Pyramid framework. OSAM evaluates stream functions across hydrology, geomorphology, and biology. It uses a debit/credit system to quantify environmental impacts and associated mitigation efforts, facilitating precise assessments and restoration planning.

Emphasis on Early Coordination
The updated regulations encourage early coordination with the EPA, allowing project proponents to engage with the agency at the pre-application stage. This proactive approach, particularly valuable for infrastructure projects like bridges and culverts, can help identify and address environmental concerns early, minimizing the risk of costly redesigns and delays.

Updated Standards for Culvert Design and Installation
New culvert design and installation standards ensure compliance with Nationwide Permit Conditions or Regional General Permits. These standards are intended to maintain stream continuity and minimize ecological disruptions that could affect aquatic habitats and lead to erosion.

Entrust EnviroScience Experts to Help Navigate the Latest Ohio EPA Regulations on Wetlands and Streams

How EnviroScience Can Assist

Navigating these changes can be complex, but EnviroScience offers a comprehensive suite of services to help clients through every step:

Wetland and Stream Delineation
Our experts conduct detailed assessments to identify and map wetlands and streams on your property, ensuring precise alignment with regulatory requirements.

Permitting Assistance
We prepare and submit permit applications, including 401 Water Quality Certifications and 404 Permits, streamlining approval and reducing the risk of delays.

Mitigation Planning and Implementation
EnviroScience develops and executes mitigation plans in line with Ohio EPA’s standards, ensuring all environmental impacts are properly managed.

Early Coordination Support
We facilitate early engagement with regulatory agencies, helping identify potential environmental issues and develop proactive strategies.

With EnviroScience’s expertise, clients can meet Ohio’s regulatory requirements while keeping projects on track. For more information on how we can support your project, please visit our Wetlands & Streams Services page at https://www.enviroscienceinc.com/services/wetlands-streams/.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.




EnviroScience Diatom Experts Shine at NADS 2024

From October 2-6, 2024, EnviroScience Algal Taxonomist Kyle Scotese, Algal/Toxin Operations Manager Brad Bartelme, and Algal Taxonomist Alison Frohn attended the 27th North American Diatom Symposium (NADS) at Iowa Lakeside Laboratory in Milford, Iowa.

EnviroScience Diatom Taxonomists Attend NADS 2024

This internationally recognized event, celebrating its 50th anniversary, brought together diatom researchers across North America to advance knowledge in biodiversity, ecology, paleolimnology, and more. NADS is renowned for its unique blend of rigorous scientific inquiry and a welcoming atmosphere, fostering collaboration and learning at every level.

New Diatom Species Stauroneis Marginistriata Discovered by EnviroScience Diatom Taxonomist Kyle Scotese

EnviroScience’s participation in this annual event is a direct reflection of our ongoing commitment to leadership in diatom research and ecological services. Kyle Scotese delivered an exciting presentation unveiling a new diatom species, Stauroneis marginistriata, discovered in groundwater seeps at Stebbins Gulch Natural Area in Holden Arboretum. This discovery highlights EnviroScience’s expertise and adds valuable insights into diatom diversity in groundwater ecosystems.

EnviroScience Diatom Taxonomist Kyle Scotese Presents New Species at NADS 2024EnviroScience diatomists in attendance are each certified at Level II in diatom taxonomy through the Society for Freshwater Science; they are three of only a handful of diatomists who have this level of certification in the entire world—a testament to their advanced knowledge and capabilities. All three trained under the guidance of Dr. Jeff Johansen at John Carroll University and were excited to reconnect with their mentor during the symposium. EnviroScience leadership identifies ongoing professional development and academic collaboration as pivotal to maintaining excellence and innovation across all service areas.

EnviroScience Diatom Taxonomists Reconnect with John Carroll Mentor

The symposium provided opportunities for hands-on workshops, including training in diatom taxonomic certification, and featured innovative presentations and poster sessions. Events like the “Scum Run” race and a lively auction supporting student scholarships added to the camaraderie while advancing the field of diatom research. The team returned to EnviroScience with enhanced expertise and new connections, ready to apply their expanded knowledge to help clients meet regulatory compliance and achieve project success.

At EnviroScience, our diatom experts bring world-class knowledge to every project—from biological assessments to water quality monitoring and algae identification. Learn more about how our laboratory services can support your project’s success by visiting our Algae Identification, Analysis, and Lab Services page.


Few environmental firms in the country retain EnviroScience’s degree of scientific know-how, talent, and capability under one roof. The diverse backgrounds of our biologists, environmental engineers, scientists, and divers enable us to provide comprehensive in-house services and an integrated approach to solving environmental challenges—saving clients time, reducing costs, and ensuring high-quality results.

Our client guarantee is to provide “Excellence in Any Environment,” meaning no matter what we do, we will deliver on our Core Values of respect, client advocacy, quality work, accountability, teamwork, and safety. EnviroScience was created with the concept that we could solve complex problems by empowering great people. This concept still holds true today as our scientists explore the latest environmental legislation and regulations and incorporate the most up-to-date technology to gather and report data.

EnviroScience expertise includes but is not limited to aquatic surveys (including macroinvertebrate surveys and biological assessments); ecological restoration; ecological services (including impact assessments, invasive species control, and water quality monitoring); emergency response; engineering and compliance services; endangered mussel surveys; laboratory and analysis; stormwater management; sustainability services; threatened and endangered species; and wetlands and streams (including delineation and mitigation). Further, EnviroScience is one of the few biological firms in the country that is a general member of the Association of Diving Contractors International (ADCI) and offers full-service commercial diving services.